

Which Football Fans Know Their Football Best? The PlayPredictWin Supporter League So Far
Play Predict Win
Founder and Lead Analyst
Manchester United are top of the league, Arsenal are chasing, Manchester City are lurking, and FC United are giving the big boys a run for their money. Welcome to the PlayPredictWin Supporter League, where football fans are doing the talking.
Let's start with something Manchester United supporters haven't had many opportunities to celebrate recently.
They're top of the league.
Yes, you read that correctly. Not the Premier League. Not the Champions League. The PlayPredictWin Supporter League.
And while the football on the pitch might not always be going to plan, United supporters are certainly delivering when it comes to predicting results. But there's much more to this competition than Manchester United sitting at the summit.
Arsenal and Manchester City are battling for second place, Liverpool and Chelsea are trying to keep pace, and some of the most impressive performances are coming from supporters of clubs you might not expect. So, what have we learned from the Supporter League so far? And which football fans really know their football?
Let's take a closer look.
First, What Is the PlayPredictWin Supporter League?
The concept is simple. When you register with PlayPredictWin, you choose the football club you support. Every time you predict a football score correctly, you earn points. And those points don't just count towards your individual position.
They also contribute to your chosen club's Supporter League total.
An exact score earns three points, a correct match result earns one point, and the Double Up feature gives you the opportunity to double your points on one selected fixture each gameweek. The more points a club's supporters collectively earn, the higher that club climbs.
It's a football league where the fans, rather than the players, determine the results. And unlike the Premier League, your club doesn't need a £100 million striker to challenge for the title. Just supporters who know their football.
Manchester United Are Setting the Pace
Let's give credit where it's due. Manchester United supporters have made an impressive start to the competition. With 4,913 points from 78 supporters in the standings on 17 November, United have established a commanding lead. That's 1,508 points ahead of second-placed Arsenal. And 1,845 points ahead of Manchester City.
| Position | Club | Points | Supporters |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Manchester United | 4,913 | 78 |
| 2 | Arsenal | 3,405 | 78 |
| 3 | Manchester City | 3,068 | 50 |
| 4 | Liverpool | 2,068 | 34 |
| 5 | Chelsea | 1,833 | 35 |
| 6 | FC United of Manchester | 1,806 | 12 |
| 7 | Tottenham Hotspur | 1,026 | 9 |
| 8 | Everton | 836 | 8 |
| 9 | Newcastle United | 713 | 13 |
| 10 | Leeds United | 561 | 9 |

United have benefited from having the joint-largest supporter contingent in the competition, level with Arsenal. But that shouldn't take anything away from their achievement. With 78 supporters contributing, they're generating an impressive number of points across the gameweeks. And there's another interesting observation.
United are averaging approximately 63.0 points per registered supporter, compared with Arsenal's 43.7. That's a substantial difference.
Of course, points per registered supporter aren't the same as prediction accuracy. Some participants may have joined earlier, submitted more predictions or played more gameweeks than others. Nevertheless, United's supporters are setting the standard in the overall competition.
What we've learned: Having a strong supporter base makes a big difference, but getting those fans actively involved is equally important.
Arsenal vs Manchester City: A Familiar Rivalry
If Manchester United are setting the pace, the battle immediately behind them is developing into an interesting contest. Arsenal sit second with 3,405 points. Manchester City are third with 3,068. Just 337 points separate the two clubs.
But there's a twist.
Arsenal have 78 supporters contributing to their total. Manchester City have just 50. That means City's supporters are generating more points per registered fan.
| Club | Total points | Supporters | Points per fan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arsenal | 3,405 | 78 | 43.7 |
| Manchester City | 3,068 | 50 | 61.4 |
City's average is approximately 40% higher than Arsenal's. Now, that doesn't automatically mean City fans are better predictors. We'd need to compare how many predictions each supporter has submitted and their actual success rates to establish that. But it does highlight an important difference.
Arsenal have the numbers. City are generating more points per registered supporter.
If Manchester City can recruit another wave of active supporters, they could put serious pressure on Arsenal's second-place position. And with United still a long way ahead, both clubs have plenty of work to do.
FC United: The Biggest Surprise Package?
Every good football league needs an underdog story. And in the PlayPredictWin Supporter League, FC United of Manchester are providing one. While Premier League giants dominate much of the table, FC United are sitting proudly in sixth place.
Their supporters have accumulated 1,806 points. Nothing particularly unusual about that, you might think. Until you realise they've achieved it with just 12 registered supporters. That's an average of approximately 150.5 points per fan. Compare that with some of the biggest clubs in English football:
| Club | Points per registered supporter |
|---|---|
| FC United of Manchester | 150.5 |
| Tottenham Hotspur | 114.0 |
| Everton | 104.5 |
| Manchester United | 63.0 |
| Leeds United | 62.3 |
| Manchester City | 61.4 |
| Liverpool | 60.8 |
| Newcastle United | 54.8 |
| Chelsea | 52.4 |
| Arsenal | 43.7 |
Calculated from the 17 November 2026 standings. These averages measure accumulated points divided by registered supporters, not prediction accuracy.
FC United are outperforming every other club in the top ten on this particular measure. And by some distance. It suggests that their small group of supporters has been particularly productive in accumulating prediction points. Perhaps they're making more predictions. Perhaps they've been involved for longer. Or perhaps they really do know their football.
Whatever the explanation, they're certainly punching above their weight.
What we've learned: You don't need thousands of supporters to make an impact. A relatively small group of active participants can put a club among the leaders.
Tottenham: Quietly Putting Up Impressive Numbers
Tottenham supporters deserve a mention too. Spurs sit seventh with 1,026 points from just nine registered fans. That's an average of 114.0 points per supporter, second only to FC United among the top ten clubs.
For a club with such a small group of participating fans, that's an impressive points total. Imagine what might happen if another 20 or 30 Spurs supporters joined and started contributing regularly. They could quickly put pressure on the clubs above them.
Of course, recruiting supporters doesn't automatically translate into points. Those fans still need to make predictions and earn them. But Spurs have shown that a small group can make a significant contribution. And for once, Tottenham supporters might have a league table worth keeping an eye on.
The Smaller Clubs Are Making Their Mark
One of the most enjoyable aspects of the Supporter League has been seeing clubs from outside the Premier League getting involved.
Portsmouth, Blackpool, Stoke City, Huddersfield Town and others have all appeared in the standings. And some of their points-per-supporter figures are particularly interesting.
In the standings on 17 November:
- ·Portsmouth had 237 points from one supporter.
- ·Blackpool had 225 points from one supporter.
- ·Stoke City had 225 points from one supporter.
- ·Huddersfield Town had 329 points from two supporters.
On a simple points-per-fan basis, Portsmouth lead that group.
But there's an important caveat. When a club has just one supporter, that person's individual performance determines the entire average. It's not enough evidence to claim Portsmouth supporters are collectively better predictors than everyone else. What it does show is that an individual supporter can make a surprisingly big difference to their club's position. And that's one of the things we like most about the Supporter League.
Whether you support Manchester United, Portsmouth, Blackpool or a non-league club, your predictions count.
What we've learned: Football knowledge isn't restricted to the biggest clubs or the Premier League. Supporters from across the football pyramid can make their mark.
Are Bigger Fanbases Always Better?
Here's one of the most interesting questions raised by the competition.
Does having more supporters automatically make you more successful?
The answer is no. But it certainly helps.
Because the Supporter League is based on the total points accumulated by each club's supporters, clubs with more participating fans have a natural opportunity to earn more points. That partly explains why Manchester United, Arsenal and Manchester City occupy the top three positions.
However, the points-per-fan figures tell us that supporter participation matters too. A club with 20 active predictors could potentially outperform one with 100 registered supporters who rarely submit predictions. This creates two very different ways to look at the standings.
The overall Supporter League
This measures the total points earned by a club's supporters. It's the official competition table and rewards the combined efforts of everyone representing their club.
Points per registered supporter
This divides a club's accumulated points by its registered fan count. It offers another perspective on how productive each club's supporter group has been. But it's important not to confuse this with accuracy.
To establish which club's fans are genuinely the best predictors, we'd need to analyse:
- ·Total predictions submitted.
- ·Exact-score success rate.
- ·Correct-result success rate.
- ·Average points per submitted prediction.
- ·Number of active participants.
- ·Differences in how long supporters have been playing.
Those statistics would allow a more meaningful comparison of prediction performance. And that's something we'd love to explore as the competition develops.
What Have We Learned About Football Fans So Far?
Although we're still relatively early in the Supporter League's development, several interesting themes are emerging.
1. Supporter loyalty creates another reason to play
Football fans love representing their clubs.
Whether it's defending their team on social media, celebrating a derby victory or arguing about which club has the best supporters, football loyalty runs deep. The Supporter League gives that loyalty another outlet. Your predictions aren't just about your personal leaderboard position. They're also about helping your club climb above its rivals.
2. The biggest clubs attract the most participants
Manchester United, Arsenal, Manchester City and Liverpool have some of the largest supporter contingents in the current standings. That's perhaps unsurprising given their large fanbases. But it also creates an interesting challenge for smaller clubs.
Can a highly engaged group of supporters compete against clubs with considerably more participants? FC United and Tottenham are showing what's possible.
3. More supporters don't necessarily mean more points per fan
Arsenal have considerably more registered supporters than FC United. But FC United have generated a much higher average number of points per registered fan. This doesn't prove greater prediction accuracy, but it does highlight the importance of participation and accumulated performance.
4. Smaller clubs can compete with football's biggest names
One of the most encouraging aspects of the competition is the range of clubs represented.
Supporters of teams outside the Premier League are contributing points alongside fans of Manchester United, Arsenal, Liverpool and Chelsea. It's a reminder that football knowledge doesn't begin and end with the Premier League.
5. There's still plenty of room for movement
With the season continuing, the standings are far from settled. Clubs can recruit new supporters, existing participants can improve their predictions and positions can change as more fixtures are played. The Supporter League is a competition that can develop throughout the season. And that's what makes it interesting.
Who Are the Best Football Predictors?

It's the question everyone wants answered.
Which club has the most knowledgeable supporters?
Manchester United fans might point to their commanding overall lead.
FC United fans might highlight their impressive points-per-supporter average.
Portsmouth supporters might argue that their single representative is doing an extraordinary job.
And Arsenal and Manchester City fans will probably have their own opinions.
But the fairest answer is that we don't have enough information yet to declare one club's supporters the most accurate predictors. The official table tells us which clubs have earned the most combined points. Points per registered supporter provides another useful comparison. Neither measure, on its own, establishes which group is best at predicting individual match outcomes.
To answer that properly, we need to compare prediction accuracy across a meaningful number of submitted forecasts. And that's where the Supporter League could become even more interesting. As more fans join and more results are recorded, we'll have an increasingly valuable dataset showing how supporters from different clubs approach football predictions.
Could we eventually discover which fans are the most optimistic about their own teams?
Which supporters predict the most exact scores?
Which club's fans are best at spotting unexpected results?
And which supporters are the most consistent over an entire season?
Those are the questions we want to explore.
Can Anyone Catch Manchester United?
With United holding such a commanding lead, the obvious question is whether anyone can catch them. Arsenal have plenty of supporters contributing. Manchester City have a strong points-per-fan average. Liverpool and Chelsea remain within the leading group. And FC United are showing that smaller clubs can generate impressive totals.
But United have built a substantial advantage.
Closing that gap will require other clubs to recruit more active supporters, make successful predictions and consistently accumulate points. Of course, United's supporters aren't going to stop playing either. If they continue at their current pace, they'll be difficult to catch.
Then again, football has a habit of producing unexpected comebacks.
And unlike the Premier League, the Supporter League doesn't depend on what happens in your own club's matches. Your supporters can earn points predicting fixtures involving teams from across the competition. So there's still everything to play for.
How Can You Help Your Club Climb the Supporter League?
The good news is that every football supporter can get involved. And you don't need to be an expert. Simply join PlayPredictWin, choose your club and start predicting football scores. Every point you earn contributes towards your club's total.
Three ways to make a difference
1. Make your predictions regularly
The more eligible fixtures you predict, the more opportunities you have to earn points. Missing an entire gameweek means missing opportunities to contribute.
2. Do your homework
Use the PlayPredictWin Club Guides to research teams, review recent form and understand upcoming fixtures. A little research can help you make more informed predictions.
3. Get your fellow supporters involved
Share the Supporter League with your mates, supporters' groups and fellow fans. If you're a Portsmouth supporter, imagine the impact of another 20 active Pompey fans joining. Or if you're an Arsenal fan, why not recruit enough Gooners to close the gap on United? The more active supporters your club has, the greater its opportunity to accumulate points. And best of all, PlayPredictWin is completely free to enter.
The Final Whistle: The Fans Are Taking Over
So, what have we learned from the PlayPredictWin Supporter League so far?
Manchester United supporters have established themselves as the team to beat in the overall standings. Arsenal and Manchester City are developing an intriguing battle for second place. FC United and Tottenham are punching well above their weight on points per registered supporter. And fans of Portsmouth, Blackpool, Stoke City and other clubs are proving that you don't need to support a Premier League giant to make an impact.
But perhaps the biggest lesson is this:
Football fans love a league table. Especially one where they can make a difference themselves.
The Supporter League gives supporters another reason to follow the weekend's fixtures, celebrate correct predictions and enjoy some friendly rivalry. And as more clubs and fans get involved, the competition should become even more interesting.
Will Manchester United stay top? Can Arsenal hold off Manchester City? Will FC United continue to embarrass the Premier League giants? And could a club currently outside the top ten make a surprise charge up the standings?
There's only one way to find out.
Your Club. Your Points. Your Pride.
Think your club has the most knowledgeable supporters in football? Then it's time to prove it.
Join PlayPredictWin, select your favourite club and start predicting football scores. Every correct prediction earns points for you and your club. You can also compete for individual weekly, monthly and season cash prizes. It's free to enter, and there's no betting involved.
Don't just support your club. Help them climb the league.
18+. Free to enter. Competition rules apply. Statistics based on the Supporter League standings on 17 November 2026; live standings may differ.
Ready to test your prediction skills?
Join the Prediction League →
